Who Should Finance Science?

It’s About Much More Than Just Money

What at first glance appears to be a purely monetary question reveals, upon closer examination, a depth that goes far beyond the simple observation that the state — any state — simply lacks the means to finance research to the extent that we scientists dream of. The inevitable consequence: We, our employers, and institutes find ourselves compelled to turn our gaze towards business and industry in search of financial support.

Not am member yet? Read this article for free.

Those Who Pay Always Demand Influence

Certainly, we are aware that we are entering a field of tension. We expose ourselves to pressure, enter into dependencies, and risk our research being influenced unilaterally in favor of those who foot the bill. In German-speaking countries, there is an apt saying for this: “He who pays the piper calls the tune.” It’s a question of power. How far this power extends its threads in the scientific enterprise can all too often be recognized in studies bearing the telltale note: “Funded by Company XY.”

I confess, it gives me a certain “pleasure” to scrutinize such publications and dissect them in seminars on scientific work with students. I also frequently discuss this topic with colleagues: How would this or…